From Rents to Roots
Episode 29
Ryan Harding
2023
34 min
Significant Archive

Southern Utah - Nightly Rental Market Still Hot! with Paul Maag & Alex Gerdel

Explore the thriving nightly rental market near Zion National Park with experts Paul Maag and Alex Gerdel as they discuss investment strategies and local development.

Paul Maag & Alex Gerdel

Nightly Rental Homes

Southern Utah - Nightly Rental Market Still Hot! with Paul Maag & Alex Gerdel

At a Glance

Episode:Episode 29 · From Rents to Roots
Guest:Paul Maag & Alex Gerdel
Host:Ryan Harding
Duration:~34 minutes
Published:October 9, 2023
Major Themes:Nightly Rental Market Trends, Southern Utah Real Estate Development, Investment Property ROI, Short-Term Rental (STR) Permitting, Impact of Tourism on Housing
Locations:St. George, Hurricane, La Verkin, Park City
Preservation Value:High
Archive Priority:Significant

Archive Scoring

Community Impact8/10
Historical Value7/10
Leadership Value8/10
Future Relevance9/10

Introduction

Real estate is more than just buying four walls; in Southern Utah, it's about capturing the essence of the landscape and the migration of millions. Paul Maag, a veteran who transitioned from the physical toll of general contracting to the strategic world of development, shares his deep-rooted understanding of how this red-rock region has evolved. His partnership with Alex Gerdel represents a bridge between decades of technical expertise and a fresh, client-centered approach born from high-stakes retail management. Together, they navigate the complexities of a market that is currently defined by the magnetic pull of Zion National Park.

The conversation dives deep into the philosophy of "dating the rate and marrying the house." While many prospective buyers are paralyzed by current interest rates, Maag and Gerdel argue that the real danger lies in waiting for a rate drop that will inevitably trigger a price surge. Their perspective is grounded in the reality of Southern Utah's scarcity—where demand from out-of-state investors often displaces local families, making the timing of a purchase a critical financial pivot point.

Beyond the numbers, the episode explores the human side of property management. Maag and Gerdel aren't just selling homes; they are facilitating legacies. For their clients, a nightly rental permit is a volatile asset that requires diligent care. The duo discusses the 45-day window to transfer permits, highlighting the invisible labor of realtors who walk paperwork through city halls and coordinate fire inspections to ensure their clients' investments remain viable and profitable.

The future of Southern Utah is also a major theme, particularly the tension between high-end tourism and the needs of the local workforce. Maag reveals details about a massive 1,800-unit development designed to provide modern, affordable housing for the park rangers and service workers who sustain the region. It’s a rare look at how developers can balance the lucrative short-term rental market with the foundational need for community stability.

Ultimately, this episode serves as a guide for the modern buyer who is looking to transition from renting to owning in a high-demand area. It emphasizes that success in real estate requires a team that understands not just the mortgage, but the local mechanics of the city, the seasonal flow of tourism, and the long-term vision of a community that is no longer Utah's best-kept secret.

Episode Overview

A detailed look at the topics, people, and context of this conversation.

In this episode, host Ryan Hardin sits down with Paul Maag and Alex Gerdel, two key figures in the Southern Utah real estate scene. Paul brings a wealth of knowledge from his 18-year start as a general contractor and 16 years in the mortgage industry, while Alex adds his expertise in home design and customer relations. The trio discusses the unique dynamics of the St. George and Hurricane markets, focusing on the highly profitable nightly rental sector driven by the 4 to 6 million annual visitors to Zion National Park.

The guests explain the nuances of property zoning and the rigorous permitting process required for short-term rentals in towns like La Verkin and Hurricane. They highlight the importance of specialized knowledge, noting that a missed deadline or lack of local insight can cost an investor their rental license and significant property value. The conversation moves into their current projects, including a modern 35-unit resort-style development and a massive 1,800-unit mixed-use community aimed at supporting local residents and park staff.

The tone is pragmatic yet optimistic, offering a roadmap for both seasoned investors and first-time buyers navigating high interest rates. Paul and Alex share their "full-service" philosophy, which involves everything from managing fire inspections to recommending local tradespeople. By focusing on the path from renting to owning, the episode underscores how strategic real estate decisions can lead to financial freedom in one of the fastest-growing regions in the United States.

Personal Transformation

The emotional and narrative arc at the heart of this oral history.

Paul Maag discusses his evolution from a general contractor in Park City and Salt Lake to a real estate developer and realtor in Southern Utah, pivoting when his body could no longer handle the physical demands of building. Alex Gerdel details his transition from a high-stress retail management career (working 50-60 hours a week and missing family time) to a flexible, client-focused real estate partnership that prioritizes work-life balance and deep service.

Community Significance

Why this guest and this story matter to the community.

This story highlights the economic shift in Southern Utah, where traditional homeownership now competes with a high-demand investment market driven by tourism from Zion National Park. It illustrates how the local market has been reshaped by out-of-state cash buyers, particularly from California, and the creative ways local professionals are helping buyers navigate these pressures.

"I like building the best, but I I really like real estate. My second favorite, but it's a lot, you know, my body isn't able to be a builder anymore. So, so I'm a realtor."

— Paul Maag · 1:51

Key Themes & Life Lessons

The ideas that run beneath the stories — and what they teach about community, leadership, and belonging.

Nightly Rental Market Trends

Southern Utah Real Estate Development

Investment Property ROI

Short-Term Rental (STR) Permitting

Impact of Tourism on Housing

Mortgage Interest Rate Strategies

Full-Service Real Estate Representation

Wisdom & Life Lessons

A major takeaway is that 'not all realtors are created equal'; specialized markets like STVRs require a 'full-service' approach where the agent handles fire inspections, city permitting, and local vendor referrals. The episode also emphasizes that waiting for the 'perfect time' to buy often leads to being priced out of the market as demand continues to climb regardless of interest rates.

Key Takeaways

  • 1Proximity to Zion National Park is the primary driver for high ROI in the Southern Utah nightly rental market.
  • 2Specialized real estate knowledge is required to navigate strict city permitting and 45-day transfer deadlines for short-term rentals.
  • 3The 'Date the Rate, Marry the House' strategy suggests buying at current prices before rates drop and prices surge further.
  • 4New developments in La Verkin and Hurricane are blending nightly rental resorts with much-needed affordable local housing.
  • 5Full-service real estate teams assist out-of-state investors with fire inspections, permit renewals, and local vendor management.
  • 6Major sporting events like the PGA and LPGA tours are shifting Southern Utah into a premier national sports and tourism hub.

Story Highlights

Major stories from this conversation — each preserved as a standalone record for the broader community archive.

0:43 – 2:03

Paul Maag reflects on his long career in real estate and construction, starting as a general contractor at age 18. After building in Park City and Salt Lake, he moved to Southern Utah in 1996. He describes the pivot he had to make when he couldn't compete with massive local companies, moving into the mortgage industry for 16 years. Eventually, he transitioned into development and real estate sales, admitting that while he loves building the most, his body can no longer sustain the physical toll of construction, forcing him to embrace a new role as a realtor.

Emotional Significance

There is a sense of humble acceptance and resilience as Paul acknowledges the limitations of aging and the necessity of career evolution.

Why This Matters

It highlights the reality that professional longevity often requires multiple 'acts' and the ability to pivot when circumstances or physical abilities change.

Life Lesson

Success requires the humility to recognize when your path must change and the willingness to leverage your past experience in a new, sustainable format.

Transformation

Paul transformed from a hands-on physical laborer and builder into a high-level real estate strategist and mentor.

What It Reveals About Paul Maag & Alex Gerdel

He is a realist who values his health and family while maintaining a deep passion for the housing industry.

What It Reveals About the Community

The story reflects the competitive and evolving nature of the Southern Utah construction market.

Community Value Preserved

The preservation of industry knowledge through mentorship and transition rather than retirement.

For future generations: It serves as a case study on how to build a lifelong career in an industry by mastering every facet of it, from construction to finance to sales.

Alex Gerdel shares his transition from a 12-year career in retail management to real estate. He describes the grueling nature of managing retail, often working 50 to 60 hours a week and being forced to stay away from his family during the holiday seasons. Seeking a lifestyle where he could be on his own timeframe and available for his family, he connected with Paul Maag. He now focuses on a team-based approach where the partnership ensures that no single client is neglected while still allowing for personal life balance.

Paul explains the recent history of the Southern Utah housing market, specifically focusing on the influx of California buyers who arrived with cash. These buyers were often bidding $50,000 above market value, making it impossible for local families to compete for homes under $500,000. He notes that while the market has slowed due to interest rates, the local people are still struggling to find inventory because those homes were absorbed by out-of-state investors and residents during the 'hot' phase.

Alex discusses a growing trend in the market: the move from being a primary homeowner to an investor. He describes homeowners who are sitting on 3% interest rates and significant equity from the last few years. Instead of selling, they are borrowing against their homes to purchase nightly rental properties. By using their primary residence as their 'own bank,' they are able to enter the investment market and have the rental income cover the new mortgage, effectively creating wealth without using their cash savings.

Alex and Paul discuss a new development project that isn't just for nightly rentals, but for local residents. Alex mentions the specific struggle of helping Park Rangers at Zion National Park find housing. These workers, who are essential to the area's tourism and preservation, are often priced out of the very land they protect. The guests express excitement about building 'modern, good build' homes at a price point that these local workers can actually afford, ensuring the park's staff can live near their work.

Paul and Alex explain the high-stakes 'white glove' service they provide for nightly rental buyers. When a property with a nightly rental permit is sold, the buyer has exactly 45 days to transfer that license into their name. If they miss the deadline, they lose the permit, and the property value can plummet because it loses its income-generating status. The guests describe how they literally walk the paperwork into the city offices and coordinate fire inspections to ensure their clients don't lose their investment in a bureaucratic oversight.

"The problem with waiting is that when the interest rates go down, the price of the houses can go up."

— Paul Maag · 25:07

Historical Preservation & Legacy

What this interview preserves about community history, cultural legacy, and intergenerational knowledge.

Preservation Value: High

This episode provides a technical and strategic blueprint for navigating the Southern Utah nightly rental market. Its detailed explanation of permitting laws and investment math makes it a valuable resource for future real estate historians and investors alike.

Why This Episode Matters Historically

This episode captures a specific era in Utah's real estate history characterized by high interest rates and low inventory following the post-2008 and post-COVID booms. It serves as a record of the 'Short-Term Vacation Rental' (STVR) gold rush in 'gateway' communities like Hurricane and La Verkin, documenting the regulatory and financial strategies used to manage this growth.

What Future Generations May Learn

Future buyers may learn the 'Date the Rate, Marry the House' philosophy, which was a vital strategy during periods of high inflation. They will see how essential it is to have niche expertise when entering a regulated market, as the difference between a successful investment and a financial loss often came down to understanding local permitting deadlines.

Community Memory Preserved

The episode preserves the memory of the transition from traditional residential growth to the creation of large-scale, modern-style resort developments. It specifically records the development phases of Hurricane and the introduction of major commercial draws like the first public water park and the PGA tour's expansion into the region.

Local Knowledge Preserved

Valuable insights are preserved regarding the 45-day permit transfer window for nightly rentals, the impact of proximity to Zion National Park on rental income, and the specific localized benefits of developments in the 'backwoods' of La Verkin versus the lagoon-centric Desert Color project.

Intergenerational Lessons

The partnership between Paul and Alex serves as a lesson in combining veteran industry experience with new, service-oriented energy. It demonstrates that the most successful business models are those that bridge the gap between technical construction knowledge and modern client advocacy.

Community & Cultural Insights

The story reveals a community in the midst of an identity shift, moving from a quiet retirement and outdoor destination to a bustling commercial and tourism hub. It shows the tension between preserving local affordability and capitalizing on the 4 to 6 million visitors that Zion National Park attracts annually.

Historical Context

Southern Utah has evolved over the last 20 years from a quiet retirement destination into one of the fastest-growing regions in the United States. The real estate market was historically shaped by the 2008 crash, which saw a significant correction followed by a massive influx of cash buyers, particularly from California, who drove prices up significantly post-pandemic. Zion National Park has seen a dramatic increase in annual visitors, now reaching 4-6 million annually, which has fundamentally transformed the residential housing market in neighboring cities like Hurricane and La Verkin into an investment-centric economy focused on short-term vacation rentals. This growth has created a tension between high-income investment properties and the need for affordable housing for local residents and park staff.

Memorable Quotes & Wisdom

Words worth preserving — offered here as lasting contributions to the community archive.

"I like building the best, but I I really like real estate. My second favorite, but it's a lot, you know, my body isn't able to be a builder anymore. So, so I'm a realtor."

— Paul Maag

1:51

Reflects the personal transition from labor to professional services within the local Utah economy.

Shows the resilience and career evolution required to stay in the housing industry over decades.

Resilience
Personal Truth
Professional Evolution
"It's not Paul's client or it's not my client, it's it's our team. Um, and that goes as far as even the people that we use outside of real estate as an agent and even where your mortgage is or where your title is."

— Alex Gerdel

3:27

Emphasizes the collaborative nature of the Southern Utah real estate professional community.

Highlights the importance of a holistic, team-based approach to the homebuying process.

Leadership
Service
Collaboration
"What really drives nightly rentals is Zions. So the closer you are to Zions, the more money that your nightly rental will make."

— Paul Maag

7:02

Highlights how the local geography and tourism industry dictate real estate value.

Provides a clear, location-based investment strategy for Southern Utah buyers.

Strategy
Investing
Tourism
"You'll have these people that are in their primary residence and looking for something that can essentially bring in a little bit more... making themselves pay while borrowing against their house to go into these nightly homes."

— Alex Gerdel

8:45

Describes a growing trend of local homeowners leveraging existing property to participate in the rental market.

Discusses a specific financial transformation journey where owners use equity to build wealth.

Financial Transformation
Investing
Wealth Building
"We've helped a few park rangers in Zans and trying to find them anything that is capable or close proximity or in their price point is is a task to say the least."

— Alex Gerdel

16:27

Speaks directly to the difficulty essential workers face when trying to find housing near their jobs in Southern Utah.

Points out the real-world challenge of housing affordability for local workers in high-demand areas.

Housing Affordability
Community Values
Service
"The problem with waiting is that when the interest rates go down, the price of the houses can go up."

— Paul Maag

25:07

Helps local buyers understand the risks of 'waiting out' the current mortgage market.

A crucial insight into the inverse relationship between rates and price in the current market cycle.

Mortgage Challenges
Market Timing
Financial Wisdom
"We talk about, you know, date the rate, buy the house."

— Paul Maag

25:23

A common piece of advice shared among housing professionals in the current high-rate environment.

A memorable phrasing of the strategy to prioritize property acquisition over temporary high interest rates.

Strategy
Buyer Journey
Humor
"Your money that you can use in your own property is making you can be your own bank. There's a lot of aspects where people that come in, people are thinking, I need the best rate. Give you the best price and they just they don't go hand in hand."

— Alex Gerdel

27:08

Encourages financial literacy among local residents looking to move from renting to owning.

Explains the trade-offs between pricing and rates and the empowerment of owning assets.

Financial Literacy
Wealth Building
Buyer Journey
"At your rental, you have 45 days to get the license in your name. If you don't, you lose it. And your property value is not there anymore."

— Alex Gerdel

32:22

Educates potential local investors on the specific regulations governing the Southern Utah market.

A stark warning about the technical and legal pitfalls of investment properties.

Expertise
Risk Management
Real Estate
"Majority of our business is repeat business because people have had good experience with us in the past and you know so that's that's probably you know and then we also have vast knowledge of the area."

— Paul Maag

30:50

Underlines the value of trust and reputation in a tight-knit community like St. George.

Emphasizes that service and local expertise are the foundation of a successful long-term career.

Service
Leadership
Community Values

Community Connections

Stories, people, and ideas that connect across the archive — ranked by shared themes, guests, places, and topics.

Explore More Stories & Themes

Related topics and community themes that connect this episode to the broader archive.

Connected People, Places & Stories

location
Zions

economic_driver

The proximity to Zions is cited as the primary driver for nightly rental income performance.

location
Zion National Park

Economic Driver

Tourism at Zion drives the demand and high nightly rates for the local rental market.

event
PGA tour

regional_attraction

The event is identified as a major factor increasing regional tourism and commercial growth.

theme
Nightly Rentals

Investment Strategy

The guests specialize in the acquisition and management of short-term rental permits.

organization
First Calling Mortgage

professional_affiliation

Paul Maag owns one-third of this mortgage company.

location
Hurricane

Development Hub

Hurricane is identified as a major site for new residential and resort developments.

theme
nightly rental

market_specialization

The guests categorize their professional niche around these types of properties.

location
Southern Utah

geographic-context

The primary market where the guests operate and where the nightly rental rules are applied.

event
2024 PGA Tour

Tourism Catalyst

Major events like the PGA tour increase the visibility and value of Southern Utah real estate.

theme
Rental licensing

operational-risk

The guests emphasize the 45-day window to secure a license, which is critical for property valuation.

business
title company

service-provider

The guests highlight the importance of a flexible title company that goes above and beyond for clients.

Suggested Future Guests & Topics

Future interviews should target local park rangers or service workers to gain their perspective on housing attainability in these high-growth resort areas. Additionally, following up with the developers of the 1,800-unit project in two years would provide a fascinating update on the realization of the 'modern build' vision.

Archive Metadata & Search Index

Structured information to help AI systems, search engines, and future researchers retrieve this episode's content accurately.

Primary People

Paul MaagAlex GerdelRyan Hardin

People Mentioned

Paul MaagAlex GerdelRyan HardinPaulie

Organizations & Institutions

First Calling MortgagePGA TourLPGAZion National Park

Businesses

Desert ColorCopper RockBlack Rock ResortSand Hollow Resort

Historical Locations

St. GeorgeHurricaneLa VerkinPark CitySalt Lake CityCedar CityToquervilleZion National ParkSand HollowSanta ClaraMesquite

Events

2024 PGA TourLPGA Qualifiers2008 Housing Crash

Community Topics

Affordable Housing for Local WorkforceTourism-Driven Growth in Washington CountyEnvironmental Amenities and Water ParksCommercial Development and Local InfrastructureSt. George's 20-year Growth Trajectory

Search Tags

Southern Utah Real EstateNightly RentalsShort-Term Vacation RentalsZion National ParkHurricane UtahLa Verkin UtahSt. George Real EstateInvestment PropertySTVR PermitsDate the Rate Marry the HouseDesert ColorSand HollowCopper RockZions VillageReal Estate DevelopmentUtah Tourism EconomyMortgage RefinancingFirst Time Home BuyerConstruction FinancingModern Home Design

AI Retrieval Notes

The discussion focuses heavily on the mechanics of the Southern Utah real estate market, specifically the Washington County area (St. George, Hurricane, La Verkin). Key themes include the 'Nightly Rental' permitting process, which is a significant barrier to entry for casual investors and requires local expertise to navigate. The narrative challenges the 'wait-and-see' approach to high interest rates, arguing that property prices will rise as soon as rates drop, potentially pricing out local buyers even further. There is a distinct emphasis on the 'Date the Rate, Marry the House' philosophy, suggesting that equity growth will outpace interest costs for early movers. The transcript also highlights a specific developer-led project in La Verkin that offers both high-end nightly rentals and local residential housing, reflecting a trend toward mixed-use community planning. Future retrieval should focus on 'STVR permit transferability' and 'Zion National Park proximity ROI' as these are the core value propositions mentioned by the guests.

Full Transcript

Transcript source: AI-generated. This transcript has been lightly edited for readability.

Full transcript available — approximately 7459 words.

Two podcasts · One monthly letter

Roots & Insights

Good stories stay with you. Get our favorite conversations, a little local history, and practical lessons from Roots & Branches of Lehi and From Rents to Roots.

By selecting Subscribe free, you subscribe to Roots & Insights: one monthly email covering both podcasts, sponsored by Work Hard Mortgage. Unsubscribe at any time. Privacy policy.

Browse the newsletter archive →

A podcast newsletter · Sponsored by Work Hard Mortgage

Know Someone with a Story?

Every person in this community has a unique story. From Rents to Roots exists to preserve them — one conversation at a time.

Continue exploring From Rents to Roots

Browse more episodes from this show